All episodes

Dark Poutine. Proudly and creepily Canadian

I Don't Know Why: Phil Hartman’s Murder

1 hour 12 minutes | Monday, 3 August 2026

Episode 430: On the morning of May 28, 1998, police were called to a home on Encino Avenue in Encino, California. Inside the master bedroom, they found Phil Hartman — one of the most versatile performers in the history of North American television — shot three times at close range while he slept. His wife, Brynn, had pulled the trigger sometime around 2:30 in the morning, then driven to a friend's house and confessed. By the time police arrived, she was back in the bedroom. She never came out.

Phil Hartman was 49 years old and born in Brantford, Ontario. He had just wrapped his fourth season of NewsRadio. He had a film opening in July. Behind the public face of a thriving career was a marriage under years of sustained pressure — addiction, relapse, escalating volatility, and a final argument that ended in the worst possible way. The motive was listed as unknown. It remains unknown.

Sources:


Los Angeles County Coroner Case Report, Investigator's Report, Autopsy Report & Toxicology — Case No. 98-03785

Hartman's Death: The Police Version — Time, June 3, 1998

Reaction & Sanctions — NPR, May 28, 1998

Disturbing Details Found In Phil Hartman's Autopsy Report — Grunge, 2024

The Last Days of Phil Hartman — ABC News / 20/20, 2019

Phil Hartman — People Magazine, 1998

Jon Lovitz Blames Andy Dick for Hartman's Death — CBS News, 2007

Phil Hartman Wrongful Death Lawsuit / Zoloft — Salon, 1999

Birgen Hartman on her father's Simpsons legacy — The Hollywood Reporter, 2022

Brantford to honour Phil Hartman with mural — CBC News, 2024

Phil Hartman — Canada's Walk of Fame

Phil Hartman — Brantford Walk of Fame

You Might Remember Me: The Life and Times of Phil Hartman — Mike Thomas


Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

I Don't Know Why: Phil Hartman’s Murder
Dark Poutine. Proudly and creepily Canadian

-
Use the arrow keys to increase and decrease the volume, or space to toggle mute.